1950 Chloe Widen Baugh - 1952 Betty Williams - 1953 Yulene Banek - 1954 Carma Hale (Jessup, Zeigler) - 1955 Ella Masters - 1956 Sandy Davidson - 1957 Bobbie Jones

1961 Phyllis Webb - 1962 Sandy Purdy - 1963 Pat Strole - 1964 Annette Carrvin (Bowers) - 1965 Teri Watson - 1966 Jan Miles - 1967 Paula Jones - 1968 Georgia Haller - 1969 Lynn Redman

1970 Jodi Russell (Pfersh) - 1971 Janet Snidow Roth (Perry) - 1972 Linda Carter (Larson) - 1973 Marla Meyers Zuch - 1974 Nancy Coufal (Elrod) - 1975 Barbara Williams (Seitz) (1978 Miss Rodeo Colorado & 2nd Runner up at Miss Rodeo America) - 1976 Pam Whitlock (Armstrong) - 1977 Teri Parkos (Bohlander, Griffith) - 1978 Debbie Ritch (Pech) (1979 Miss Rodeo Colorado) - 1979 Jeri Hass (Cooper)

1980 Nancy Bunjes (Nott) (Mother of the 2006 Queen) - 1981 Susan Farner (Berger) - 1982 Margaret Keehn - 1983 Penny Anderson (Constable) - 1984 Sandie Chaney - 1985 Duetta Allart - 1988 Kelly Field - 1989 Kim Daley (Kling)

1990 Heidi Carmack - 1991 Colette Willbanks - 1992 Tara Rumsey (Weber) - 1993 Kelli Metz (Mohan) - 1994 Sara Hitner (Hermosillo) - 1995 Jodi Stonner (Miller) - 2002 Amanda Milton - 2003 Stacie Toft 

2004 Bronwyn Schindler - 2005 Alyse Scebbi - 2006 Alyssa Bunjes - 2007 Chelyn Heideman - 2008 Sadie Sayler - 2009 Randi Rae Fishler